Is the "Dream School" Worth the Debt?

Every year, I watch students open their college acceptance letters with tears of joy—finally admitted to their dream school! But then comes the financial aid package, and sometimes those tears take on a different meaning. As an independent educational consultant, I'v guided countless families through one of the most emotionally charged decisions they'll ever make: Is attending that dream school worth taking on significant debt?

Let me be direct: there's no universal answer. But there are questions every family should ask before signing those loan documents.

The Debt Numbers That Actually Matter

First, let's talk numbers. The average student loan debt for 2024 graduates hovers around $30,000, but I've seen families contemplate debt loads of $80,000, $120,000, or even more for undergraduate degrees. Here's the reality check: your monthly student loan payment will be roughly 1% of your total debt. Borrow $100,000? Expect payments around $1,000 per month for ten years.

Now ask yourself: what will your starting salary likely be in your chosen field? A general rule I share with families is that your total undergraduate debt should not exceed your expected first-year salary. If you're planning to teach elementary school (median starting salary around $45,000), taking on $150,000 in debt for a private liberal arts college isn't a financial strategy—it's a financial crisis in the making.

When the Dream School Might Be Worth It

I won't tell you that prestige never matters, because sometimes it does. There are scenarios where the investment can pay dividends:

Strong alumni networks in your field. If you're aiming for Wall Street, management consulting, or certain tech sectors, the recruiting pipeline and alumni connections at elite schools can genuinely open doors that remain closed to graduates from less selective institutions.

Exceptional programs in your specific discipline. If you're admitted to MIT for engineering, Juilliard for music, or Wharton for business, you're not just buying a brand—you're accessing faculty, resources, and opportunities that may genuinely be unavailable elsewhere.

Significant but manageable debt with high-earning potential. Graduating with $40,000 in debt to pursue computer science, engineering, or nursing is a very different proposition than the same debt for a career with a lower earnings ceiling.

When It's Almost Certainly Not Worth It

After two decades in this field, I've seen patterns of regret. Here are the red flags:

You're borrowing heavily for an undecided major. If you don't know what you want to study, you're essentially taking out a six-figure loan for an experience rather than an investment. That's an expensive way to figure out your path.

You're choosing prestige over fit. I've watched students turn down full scholarships at schools where they'd thrive to attend brand-name institutions where they felt like imposters. Four years of anxiety and $100,000 in debt? That's not a dream—it's a nightmare.

Your parents are taking on the debt. When parents offer to shoulder the financial burden, it comes from love. But I've seen too many families compromise their retirement security, home equity, and financial stability. That's not a gift to you—it's a burden you'll both carry.

The "dream" is really someone else's dream. Is this truly your dream school, or is it your parents' dream, your school counselor's suggestion, or a prestige chase you think you're supposed to want?

The Questions You Need to Ask

When families come to me torn between the affordable state school and the expensive dream school, I ask them to answer these questions honestly:

• Can you articulate three specific opportunities at the expensive school that aren't available at the affordable option? Not "it's better," but actual, concrete differences.

• Will you need graduate school for your career? If so, save your borrowing power for that.

• What will your life look like at 28 years old, five years after graduation? Will you be building wealth, traveling, starting a family—or will you be sending $800 a month to a loan servicer?

• If you attend the affordable school, what could you do with the money you're not spending? Study abroad? Graduate debt-free and use savings for a startup? Fund the first years of graduate school?

• 
  

An Alternative path to Your Dreams

Here's something I've learned: successful, fulfilled people graduate from all kinds of colleges. The dream isn't really about the institution—it's about who you become and what you accomplish. And you can pursue that anywhere.

Consider these alternatives:

Start at a community college or state school, then transfer. Many elite schools have transfer pathways, and you'll cut your costs dramatically for the first two years.

Choose the affordable school and invest in experiences. Use the money you're saving to study abroad, pursue competitive internships without worrying about summer earnings, or build a portfolio that will impress employers.

Appeal your financial aid. If you're dead-set on the dream school, you might be able to negotiate a better package, especially if you have competing offers.

The Conversation You Need to Have

If you're considering significant debt for your dream school, sit down with your parents and a financial calculator. Map out exactly what those monthly payments will look like. Talk about how it will affect your ability to buy a car, rent an apartment, or save for your future. Make it real, not abstract.

And then ask the hard question: is four years at this institution worth a decade of constrained financial choices afterward?

My Take After Years in This Field

I believe in dreams. I believe in reaching high and refusing to settle. But I also believe that student debt has become one of the most significant barriers to young people actually achieving their dreams after college. I've watched brilliant graduates turn down jobs they're passionate about because they need the higher salary to manage loan payments. I've seen couples delay marriage and families because of debt loads.

Your dream school can be an incredible investment in yourself. But it can also be a very expensive mistake. The key is knowing the difference before you commit.

Choose the college where you'll thrive—academically, socially, and yes, financially. Because the real dream isn't where you go to college. It's the life you build afterward.

Are you navigating the college selection process and feeling overwhelmed by the financial implications? I'd love to help your family find the right fit—academically and financially. Contact me to schedule a consultation.